23 DIY Eyeball Halloween Decor Ideas That Will Stare Down Every Guest

There’s something deliciously unsettling about a room full of eyes that seem to follow you. Halloween gives you the perfect excuse to lean into that eerie charm, and DIY eyeball decor is an easy way to make your space feel delightfully creepy.

You can craft them big and bold to dominate a yard display, or small and sneaky to surprise guests when they least expect it.

Painted, glowing, hanging, or peeking from unexpected corners, these projects can be as silly or spine-chilling as you like.

Once you start, you might find yourself adding an eye to every Halloween vignette, just for the thrill of seeing people do a double take.

#1. Googly-Eyed Pumpkin Snail

If you want a Halloween pumpkin that’s more quirky than creepy, this googly-eyed snail design will steal the show.

The long eye stalks with cartoonish eyeballs give it a fun, unexpected twist that’s perfect for porch decor. It’s also an easy project to do with kids, since it doesn’t involve much carving.

Materials Needed

1 medium pumpkin
2 plastic eyeballs
2 bendable craft tubes or pool noodles (brown or wrapped in tape)
Hot glue gun
Knife for making small holes

Step-by-step Guide

Step 1: Cut two small holes on either side of the pumpkin’s stem. Then insert the craft tubes to create snail stalks.

Step 2: Hot glue the plastic eyeballs to the ends of each stalk.

Step 3: Adjust the angles so the eyes appear to be “looking” around.

Step 4: Place your snail pumpkin on the porch for a lighthearted Halloween surprise.

#2. Giant Paper Lantern Eyeballs

Big, bold, and impossible to miss, these oversized eyeball lanterns make a playful yet eerie statement for Halloween. Their sheer size makes them perfect for a party backdrop, yard display, or even a hallway surprise.

With just a few painted details, ordinary white paper lanterns transform into giant peepers that seem to watch every move.

You can also add spikes, lashes, or color variations to create a whole gallery of ghoulish gazes.

Materials Needed

3-5 white paper lanterns (varied sizes)
Acrylic paints (black, white, iris colors)
Paintbrushes
Black cardstock
Glue or tape

Step-by-step Guide

Step 1: Assemble the paper lanterns according to the instructions.

Step 2: Paint a large iris and pupil on each lantern, letting the paint dry fully.

Step 3: Cut lashes or spikes from black cardstock and attach around the iris edge. Then arrange the lanterns on the floor, hang them, or group them in corners for effect.

Step 4: Mix different iris colors for a more vibrant and mismatched look.

#3. Eyeball Dome Display

Look at this piece! It feels like something plucked straight from a mad scientist’s study.

Dozens of tiny blue eyes perch on spindly stems, frozen in time beneath a glass dome. It’s equal parts curiosity and creepiness, perfect for a Halloween centerpiece that sparks conversation.

The best part is that it’s easier to make than it looks, and the glass cover adds a polished, museum-like finish that elevates the eerie effect.

Materials Needed

1 glass display dome with base (8″-12″ tall)
15-20 plastic eyeballs (0.5″-1″ diameter)
15-20 artificial thistle pods or seed heads
Thin floral wire or metal picks
Hot glue gun with glue sticks

Step-by-step Guide

Step 1: Attach each eyeball to the center of a thistle pod using hot glue.

Step 2: Insert a floral wire or metal pick into the base of each pod to create stems. Then arrange the stems in the display base, varying heights for depth.

Step 3: Once you’re happy with the layout, secure the stems in place with glue or floral foam.

Step 4: Place the glass dome over the top and enjoy your eerie, high-end Halloween decor.

#4. Spiky Eyeball Plant

Imagine a plant that watches your every move, this spiky eyeball creation makes that nightmare come to life.

With its thorny seed pod lids and bloodshot eyes, it looks like something that could have sprouted in a witch’s garden.

Nestled in an ordinary pot, it catches people off guard, making them do a double take. It’s a wonderfully weird way to turn a plain houseplant into a Halloween spectacle.

Materials Needed

1-2 potted plants with leafy foliage
4-6 thorny seed pods (real or artificial)
4-6 plastic eyeballs (1″ diameter)
Hot glue gun with glue sticks
Wooden skewers

Step-by-step Guide

Step 1: Cut each seed pod in half to create an open lid for the eyeball. Then glue an eyeball into each pod half, pressing firmly so it’s secure.

Step 2: Attach the pods to wooden skewers or floral picks to create stems.

Step 3: Insert the stems into your potted plant, varying heights for a natural look.

Step 4: Adjust the leaves so they partly hide the eyes, giving a peek-a-boo effect.

#5. Eyeball Roses

At first glance, they look like elegant deep-red roses in a vase. But take a closer look, and you’ll see each bloom is hiding an unblinking eye.

This blend of beauty and horror is perfect for Halloween lovers who enjoy a touch of the unexpected.

Also, you can place them on a shelf, in an entryway, or as a table centerpiece to surprise anyone who leans in for a better look. They’re haunting, romantic, and strangely mesmerizing all at once.

Materials Needed

2-3 artificial red roses (full bloom)
2-3 plastic eyeballs (1″ diameter)
Hot glue gun with glue sticks
Wire cutters or scissors

Step-by-step Guide

Step 1: Gently pull apart the center petals of each artificial rose to make space for the eyeball.

Step 2: Apply a small amount of hot glue to the back of the eyeball and press it into the flower’s center.

Step 3: Adjust the surrounding petals so they partly frame the eye without covering it.

Step 4: Repeat for each rose, then arrange them in a vase for display.

Step 5: Position the flowers where guests can get close enough to notice the creepy twist.

#6. Jar of Preserved Eyeballs

Wow, this unsettling jar looks like it came straight from a mad scientist’s shelf. Packed with floating eyeballs in a glowing red liquid, it’s the perfect centerpiece for a haunted laboratory scene or Halloween party table.

The eerie effect is surprisingly easy to create, and with the right lighting, it can look disturbingly realistic.

Additionally, you place it among potion bottles, skulls, and candles for a full spooky display.

Materials Needed

1 large glass jar with lid
12-15 plastic eyeballs (1″ diameter)
Water
Red food coloring
Optional: submersible LED light

Step-by-step Guide

Step 1: Fill the jar halfway with water and add a few drops of red food coloring.

Step 2: Drop the plastic eyeballs into the jar, letting them float naturally. Then add more colored water until the jar is full, then screw on the lid.

Step 3: Place a submersible LED light at the bottom for an eerie glow and now display in a dimly lit area for maximum creep factor.

#7. Dangling Eyeball Earrings

If your Halloween look needs a statement piece, these dangling eyeball earrings will definitely get people talking.

The mix of blood-red detailing, twisting veins, and realistic blue irises makes them spooky yet strangely stylish. They swing with every movement, catching the light and the attention of anyone nearby.

Specially, this craft is perfect for parties, costume events, or just to freak out your friends in the most fashionable way possible.

Materials Needed

2 small plastic eyeballs (0.75″-1″ diameter)
Red polymer clay or epoxy putty
2 earring hooks
2 short lengths of chain (1.5″-2″)
Jewelry pliers
Craft glue

Step-by-step Guide

Step 1: Shape red clay into twisted vein-like strands and bake or cure according to the package instructions.

Step 2: Attach each clay piece to the top of an eyeball using craft glue.

Step 3: Connect a short chain between the clay vein and an earring hook with jewelry pliers.

Step 4: Repeat for the second earring. Then let the glue dry fully before wearing to your Halloween event.

Read more: 23 Creepy and Fun Halloween Painted Rock Ideas to Haunt Your Creativity

#8. Vintage Eyeball Display

You can see this display feels like it was pulled straight from a Victorian curiosity cabinet.

Large, sepia-toned eyeballs wrapped in printed paper rest among faux skulls and dried moss, giving it a haunting yet elegant presence.

Also, the muted colors and old-world style make it perfect for a gothic-themed Halloween setup or as part of a vintage apothecary scene. It’s eerie, sophisticated, and surprisingly easy to recreate.

Materials Needed

6-8 foam balls (varied sizes)
Printed decoupage paper or old book pages
Matte Mod Podge
Black and white printed eye graphics
Dried moss
Small decorative skulls
Shallow tray or display bowl

Step-by-step Guide

Step 1: Cover each foam ball with decoupage paper, smoothing out wrinkles as you go.

Step 2: Glue a printed eye graphic onto each ball, centering it neatly. Then arrange the eyeballs in your tray or bowl, layering with dried moss.

Step 3: Tuck small skulls between the eyeballs for added detail.

Step 4: Place the display in a prominent spot to give your guests a taste of vintage spookiness.

#9. Creepy Eyeball Phone Case

This phone case looks like it’s alive and watching. The glossy, blood-red texture is covered in dozens of eyes of every color and size, each one following you with unsettling precision.

I bet it’s a bold statement piece for Halloween, horror conventions, or anyone who loves spine-chilling accessories.

Plus, you can make it yourself and customize the number and color of eyes to suit your own creepy aesthetic.

Materials Needed

1 plain phone case (silicone or hard shell)
20-30 small plastic doll eyes (varied sizes and colors)
Red polymer clay or epoxy putty
Craft glue or epoxy adhesive
Glossy clear varnish

Step-by-step Guide

Step 1: Roll and press small strips of red clay or putty across the phone case, creating organic, vein-like shapes.

Step 2: Press the eyes into the clay, spacing them randomly for a chaotic look.

Step 3: Smooth and blend the clay edges so the eyes look embedded. Then let the clay fully cure according to package instructions.

Step 4: Now you can brush on a glossy varnish to give the case a wet, lifelike finish.

#10. Mini Eyeball Spider

Small but startling, this mini eyeball spider is the perfect Halloween prank piece. Its glossy blue iris and spindly black legs make it look like a creepy critter that just scuttled out from under the couch.

Whether you scatter a few across the table, hide them in candy bowls, or use them in party favors, these little guys are guaranteed to give guests a fun fright.

Materials Needed

Plastic spider toy
1 small plastic eyeball (1″ diameter)
Hot glue gun with glue sticks
Black acrylic paint (optional)

Step-by-step Guide

Step 1: If needed, paint the spider toy black and let it dry.

Step 2: Remove or flatten any raised detail on the spider’s back. Then apply hot glue to the spider’s back and press the eyeball firmly into place.

Step 4: Hold for a few seconds until the glue sets. Place your spider in unexpected spots for a spooky surprise and you are done!

#11. Eyeball Wreath

Welcome your Halloween guests with a stare they’ll never forget. This eerie wreath combines black blooms, twisted twigs, and unblinking eyeballs for a decoration that’s both spooky and stylish.

Moreover, the cool blue irises stand out against the dark petals, making each eye pop with an unsettling charm.

Of course, you can hang it on your front door and it will instantly set the tone for a night of chills and thrills.

Materials Needed

1 grapevine or twig wreath base (14″-16″)
8-10 plastic eyeballs (1″-1.5″ diameter)
Black artificial flowers
Hot glue gun with glue sticks
Black ribbon

Step-by-step Guide

Step 1: Arrange the black flowers evenly around the wreath base and glue them in place.

Step 2: Nestle a plastic eyeball into the center of each flower and secure with hot glue.

Step 3: Add extra eyeballs directly to the wreath in between flowers for more visual impact. Then loop the black ribbon through the top and tie a bow for hanging.

Step 4: Hang your wreath on the door and let it greet visitors with a haunting gaze.

#12. Creepy Eyeball Lantern

Glowing from within, this eyeball lantern looks like something salvaged from a haunted shipwreck.

The light flickers through a tangle of moss and the eerie red veins of the floating eyes inside, giving it an otherworldly presence.

It’s small enough to hold in your hand, yet striking enough to be the centerpiece of your Halloween table or windowsill display. Best of all, it’s quick to make with just a few supplies.

Materials Needed

1 clear jar or glass
6-8 plastic eyeballs (1″ diameter)
Green decorative moss
1 battery-operated tea light

Step-by-step Guide

Step 1: Place the tea light at the bottom of the jar. Then you add a loose layer of moss around the edges.

Step 2: Drop the eyeballs into the jar so they sit on top of the light.

Step 3: Pull some moss upward along the inside of the jar for a tangled effect.

Step 4: Finally, switch on the light and let your lantern cast its spooky glow.

#13. Eyeball Tentacle Plant

This quirky potted plant looks like it belongs in a mad scientist’s lab. Instead of leaves, it sprouts long, curling stalks tipped with colorful, bloodshot eyes that seem to follow you around the room.

It’s more silly than scary, but still eerie enough to be a perfect conversation starter for Halloween.

You can place it on a coffee table or near your entryway, and watch guests lean in for a closer look.

Materials Needed

1 small pot or container
12-15 plastic eyeballs (1″ diameter)
12-15 flexible green pipe cleaners
Floral foam or Styrofoam ball (fits inside pot)
Hot glue gun with glue sticks

Step-by-step Guide

Step 1: Glue one eyeball to the end of each pipe cleaner.

Step 2: Bend and curl the pipe cleaners to give them a tentacle-like shape.

Step 3: Insert the other ends into the floral foam inside the pot.

Step 4: Adjust the stalks so the eyes face in different directions. Then fill any gaps with extra moss or decorative filler for a finished look.

#14. Eye Martini

Nothing says “Halloween party” quite like a drink that stares back at you. This vibrant green martini is topped with a floating eyeball and a candy worm, making it equal parts creepy and fun.

It’s an easy way to impress guests at your spooky soirée, and you can make it kid-friendly or boozy depending on your crowd.

You serve them on a tray and watch everyone’s reaction as they realize their drink has a gaze of its own.

Materials Needed

Green drink mix (lime soda, punch, or green apple martini)
Plastic eyeball decorations
Gummy worms
Martini glasses

Step-by-step Guide

Step 1: Fill each martini glass with your chosen green beverage. Then drop a plastic eyeball into the drink so it floats near the surface.

Step 2: Hook a gummy worm over the rim for a playful touch and chill until ready to serve.

Step 3: Present on a tray for maximum dramatic effect.

See also: 25 Spooktacular Halloween Cupcake Ideas to Haunt Your Dessert Table

#15. Creepy Eyeball Spiders

These unsettling little critters are part spider, part staring eyeball, and entirely perfect for Halloween.

Their wiry legs make them look like they could scuttle across the table at any moment, while the realistic lashes and bloodshot details add an extra layer of creepiness.

You can also scatter them along your buffet table, tuck them into your candy bowls, or let them lurk in unexpected corners to give guests a jolt. They’re small, but once you make a few, you’ll find endless ways to use them in your spooky setup.

Materials Needed

12 plastic eyeballs (1″ diameter)
24 pieces of black wire (6″ each)
Hot glue gun with glue sticks
Black craft paint
Small paintbrush
Optional: false eyelashes

Step-by-step Guide

Step 1: Cut two pieces of wire for each spider, bending them into zigzag shapes to form legs.

Step 2: Paint the wires black and let them dry completely.

Step 3: Glue one set of legs to each side of a plastic eyeball, making sure they’re evenly spaced.

Step 4: Add false eyelashes above the eye for an extra eerie, lifelike touch.

Step 5: Let the glue set, then pose the legs so each spider looks ready to crawl.

#16. Glass Jar of Watching Eyes

Like something straight from a haunted apothecary, this tall glass jar is filled with moss and large, hand-painted eyes that seem to float in the shadows.

The muted colors and vintage look make it blend seamlessly into a creepy potion display, perfect for shelves, side tables, or your Halloween bar setup.

Bonus, it’s eerie without being over the top, and the best part is you can customize the size and style of the eyes for your own haunting vision.

Materials Needed

1 tall glass jar or vase
8-10 foam balls (varied sizes)
Acrylic paints (white, black, iris colors)
Paintbrushes
Spanish moss or dried moss

Step-by-step Guide

Step 1: Paint each foam ball with a large, stylized eye using acrylic paints and let them dry.

Step 2: Fill the bottom of the jar with a layer of moss. Then add painted eyes one at a time, tucking moss between layers for depth.

Step 3: Continue stacking until the jar is full, with some eyes facing outward.

Step 4: Place the jar among other spooky decor for maximum effect.

#17. Eyeball Ornament Tree

Who says creepy can’t be colorful? This eyeball ornament tree blends classic Halloween weirdness with a splash of glitter and holiday cheer.

The mix of bright purple, green, and gold baubles with eerie staring eyes creates a look that’s part spooky, part festive.

It’s a playful way to decorate for October that can sit proudly on a table, counter, or even as an unexpected accent in your living room.

Materials Needed

1 small black tabletop tree
6-8 glitter ornaments in assorted colors
6-8 plastic eyeball ornaments (1″-2″ diameter)
Ornament hooks

Step-by-step Guide

Step 1: Fluff and shape the branches of your tabletop tree for even spacing. Then hang the glitter ornaments first, spreading the colors evenly.

Step 2: Add the eyeball ornaments, placing them so they peek out from different angles.

Step 3: Adjust placement until the colors and eyes feel balanced.

Step4: Place the tree where it can be admired up clos so guests will love spotting the surprise eyes.

#18. Spiky Eyeball Seed Pod

It looks like something you’d stumble upon in an enchanted forest or a witch’s garden. This spiky seed pod hides a bright blue eye inside, peeking out as if it’s watching intruders.

Also, the combination of natural texture and unsettling gaze makes it a simple but striking Halloween accent.

You place a few along a windowsill, in a bowl, or scattered across your table for a creepy botanical touch.

Materials Needed

1 large spiky seed pod (real or artificial)
1 plastic eyeball (1″ diameter)
Hot glue gun with glue sticks

Step-by-step Guide

Step 1: Carefully split the seed pod into two halves, keeping the spikes intact.

Step 2: Position the eyeball between the two halves so it appears to be peeking out.

Step 3: Glue the halves together, leaving enough space for the eye to remain visible. Then let the glue dry completely before handling.

Step 4: Display as a stand-alone decoration or group several together for impact.

#19. Creeping Moss Eyeball Frame

This spooky frame looks like it has crawled out of a haunted swamp just to keep an eye on you. The twisting moss-covered branches give the illusion of movement, as if the frame is alive and watching.

Plus, the eyes peek out from unexpected spots, making it the perfect mix of eerie and fascinating.

You display it near a window or entryway for maximum effect; the natural light will make those pupils glint just enough to send shivers down spines.

Materials Needed

1 photo frame (8″×10″)
10-12 plastic eyeballs (1″ diameter)
50 g craft moss
Hot glue gun with glue sticks
Scissors

Step-by-step Guide

Step 1: Remove the glass and backing from your frame so you have an open border.

Step 2: Hot glue tufts of moss along the edges, letting them spill outward naturally.

Step 3: Nestle eyeballs into the moss at different angles, some clustered, others alone.

Step 4: Fill in gaps with extra moss for a fuller, creepier look. Then let the glue dry fully before displaying in a well-lit spot.

#20. Felted Eyeball Plant

It’s as if a cluster of strange forest creatures took root in your flowerpot. These fuzzy stalks sway slightly, each one tipped with a curious unblinking eye in shades of blue and green.

Specially, the mix of soft felt texture and eerie gaze makes this craft both charming and unsettling like a cross between a houseplant and a watchful pet.

Materials Needed

1 small terracotta pot
8-10 small plastic eyeballs (0.5″-1″ diameter)
Brown and green wool roving (for felting)
Felting needle
Hot glue gun with glue sticks
Decorative moss

Step-by-step Guide

Step 1: Felt the wool roving into long, narrow stalk shapes, blending brown for the base and green near the top.

Step 2: Glue an eyeball to the end of each stalk, pressing firmly until secure.

Step 3: Fill your terracotta pot with decorative moss to create a base. Then insert the stalks into the moss at varying angles so they appear to grow naturally.

Step 4: Fluff the moss and adjust the eyes so they’re facing in different directions.

#21. Eyeball Bracelet

This project is bold, bizarre, and impossible to ignore, an eyeball bracelet that stares back at everyone you meet.

The glossy blue irises and bloodshot veins make it perfect for Halloween parties, creepy costumes, or even as a conversation starter at casual gatherings.

Lightweight yet striking, it’s one of those accessories that can instantly add a spooky twist to any outfit.

Materials Needed

8-10 round plastic eyeballs with holes (0.75″-1″ diameter)
Stretch cord (10-12″ length)
Scissors
Clear-drying glue (optional)

Step-by-step Guide

Step 1: Cut a length of stretch cord slightly longer than your wrist measurement.

Step 2: Thread the eyeballs onto the cord, alternating the iris direction for variety.

Step 3: Once all beads are in place, tie the ends together in a tight double knot.

Step 4: Add a drop of clear glue to the knot for extra security if desired.

Step 5: You can also trim any excess cord and slip your eerie new bracelet onto your wrist.

#22. All-Seeing Eyeball Wreath

This wreath doesn’t just hang on your wall, it stares. Packed with dozens of unblinking eyes, it creates the unsettling feeling that you’re being watched from every angle.

Plus, the crisp white eyeballs against a dark wreath base make it both bold and creepy, perfect for Halloween doors, walls, or even above a mantel. It’s simple to make, but the effect is unforgettable.

Materials Needed

1 grapevine wreath base (14″-16″)
40-50 plastic eyeballs (1″ diameter)
Hot glue gun with glue sticks
Black spray paint (optional)

Step-by-step Guide

Step 1: If desired, spray paint your wreath base black and let it dry completely.

Step 2: Glue eyeballs one by one around the wreath, keeping them close together for a dense look.

Step 3: Rotate the direction of the eyes so they don’t all face the same way.

Step 4: Fill any gaps with extra glue to secure the eyeballs firmly. Now you can hang your wreath where it can give visitors that someone’s watching vibe.

#23. Creepy Eyeball String Lights

Why not give your Halloween decor an eerie glow with these eyeball string lights? They’re the perfect mix of spooky and fun, adding a watchful presence to any dark corner or outdoor tree.

The soft illumination combined with the staring blue irises will keep guests feeling like they’re being followed all night long.