Fold your fabric in half and draw a heart shape about 6 inches wide. Cut out two identical heart pieces for each ornament. Mix fabrics, try pairing burlap with plaid or floral cotton for contrast.
Place the two heart pieces together (right sides facing each other if using patterned fabric) and sew along the edges, leaving a small opening at the bottom.
Turn the heart inside out so the seams are hidden, then gently stuff it with fiberfill until plump but soft. Then stitch the opening closed with small, neat stitches.
Glue or sew a ribbon loop to the top center of each heart for hanging. If you want extra flair, add bows, lace trim, or small buttons at the front.
To finish, lightly fray the edges of the burlap or pull a few threads for a rustic look. Hang your hearts on garlands, doors, or even Christmas trees for a homespun touch of love.